Is Instacart Worth It? Pros, Cons, and What You Need to Know

Is Instacart worth it? If you’re looking for a convenient way to get groceries delivered, this question is crucial. We’ll explore the pros, cons, costs, and overall value of Instacart to help you decide if it’s right for you.

Short Summary

What Is Instacart?

Delivery man giving groceries order to customer
Image by freepik on Freepik

Instacart is an innovative grocery delivery platform that connects users with local stores, allowing them to order groceries online and have them delivered to their homes. This service not only offers grocery delivery but also curbside pickup options, catering to a variety of customer preferences.

What sets Instacart apart from other grocery delivery services is the range of stores it partners with. Users can select items from various types of stores, including grocery stores, pet supply stores, and even home improvement stores. This means you can order your groceries, pet food, and home essentials all in one go, making it incredibly convenient. Instacart is also widely accessible across the U.S. and Canada, with the capability for same-day deliveries from numerous grocery chains.

Instacart enhances the shopping experience with personalized recommendations and easy reordering based on your previous purchases. You can also leave notes for your personal shopper regarding any substitutions or specific preferences for out-of-stock items. This level of customization ensures that your grocery order meets your exact needs and preferences.

Instacart+ Membership

Frequent users may find Instacart+ (formerly known as Instacart Express) a worthwhile investment. Instacart+ is a paid subscription that offers several benefits, including unlimited free delivery on orders over $35 and a 5% credit back on pickups. Additionally, subscribers gain access to a Peacock Premium subscription and the option to share their account with family members.

The cost of an Instacart+ membership is $99 per year. While this may seem steep at first glance, the savings can add up quickly if you find yourself frequently ordering groceries. With reduced service fees and exclusive benefits, the membership can essentially pay for itself, especially if you make regular use of the service.

Is Instacart Worth It for You?

Empty toy shopping carts on a wooden table
Image by rorozoa on Freepik

Deciding whether Instacart is worth it depends largely on your individual needs and circumstances. Older adults, people with disabilities, or anyone who finds in-person shopping challenging may find Instacart a game-changer. It offers significant convenience for individuals with limited mobility or those who simply dislike the hassle of grocery shopping.

However, there are some limitations to consider. Instacart may not be available in rural areas where there are fewer grocery stores or shoppers. Additionally, while the service can be incredibly convenient, it does come with added costs, including delivery fees, service fees, and potential price markups on items.

If you can afford these fees and lack alternative delivery services, Instacart might be a worthwhile option for you.

Cost Vs. Convenience

Weighing the cost versus convenience of Instacart is crucial. While there’s no denying the convenience of having groceries delivered to your doorstep, it’s important to consider the associated costs. These include membership fees, delivery fees, and service fees. An Instacart+ membership becomes financially beneficial after around 25 deliveries without Peacock or 10 deliveries with Peacock. Service fees can vary based on your location and the specific items in your cart, which can add to the overall cost.

However, the convenience factor is significant. Using grocery delivery services like Instacart can help you avoid impulse buying since you’re not physically present in a store. Plus, the time saved from not having to shop in person can be invaluable. The opportunity cost — the value of the time you save — can often outweigh the extra money spent on delivery and service fees.

Time Savings

One of the most compelling reasons to use Instacart is the time savings. Imagine not having to spend hours navigating crowded grocery store aisles as in store shoppers do. Instacart saves you time by having a personal shopper pick up your groceries for you. The Instacart Shopper app is designed to be efficient, grouping items by store sections and providing easy access to frequently purchased items via the ‘Buy It Again’ tab.

Moreover, Instacart offers multiple delivery options, including scheduled deliveries and same day delivery. Many customers have reported that their items are well-bagged and delivered on time, contributing to overall satisfaction. This flexibility allows you to plan your grocery deliveries around your schedule, ensuring you never run out of essentials.

Quality and Accuracy

Quality and accuracy are common concerns when it comes to grocery delivery. Some users worry about the quality of fresh produce delivered by Instacart. There have been instances where wrong items were selected, leading to dissatisfaction.

However, communication with your Instacart shopper can significantly improve your experience. Leaving detailed notes about your preferences, especially for perishable items like fruits and vegetables, helps ensure that the items you receive meet your standards. This proactive approach can mitigate many of the common issues associated with quality and accuracy.

How Much Does Instacart Cost?

Woman checking her delivery of groceries
Image by freepik on Freepik

Understanding the costs associated with Instacart is essential for making an informed decision. While a membership isn’t required to use Instacart, the Instacart+ membership costs $99 per year. This membership offers benefits like free delivery on orders over $35 and reduced service fees, which can add up to significant savings for frequent users.

Delivery fees on Instacart depend on factors such as the retailer, the delivery window, and the order total. It’s important to consider these variables when calculating the overall cost of using the service, including the delivery fee. Knowing the potential costs upfront can help you decide if Instacart’s convenience is worth the investment.

Delivery Fees

Instacart’s delivery fees start at $3.99 for orders above $35, with a minimum order requirement of $10. However, additional charges may apply for priority delivery or smaller orders, which can increase the total delivery cost.

These fees can be more affordable compared to some other delivery services, but they can become expensive when combined with service fees and tips. It’s essential to factor in these potential costs when evaluating Instacart’s affordability.

Service Fees

Service fees on Instacart can accumulate quickly, making it one of the pricier grocery delivery options. The minimum service fee ranges from $3 to $4, depending on your location and the items in your cart. Additionally, Instacart temporarily charges a higher amount on your card to cover potential bag and bottle fees, as well as costlier substitutions.

After delivery, the final charge on your card should match the receipt, ensuring that you only pay for what you receive. Understanding these service fees can help you better budget for your grocery deliveries.

Tips and Gratuities

Tipping is an important aspect of the Instacart experience. While tips are separate from service fees, they go directly to the shopper and can significantly impact the quality of service you receive. A generous tip can incentivize your shopper to handle your groceries with extra care, ensuring a better overall experience.

How Do Instacart Shoppers Get Paid?

Instacart shoppers earn money by buying and delivering groceries from partnered local stores. They can work either as part-time employees or freelancers, which affects their pay structure. Shoppers are paid weekly, with earnings from the previous week becoming available around Wednesday.

The flexibility in working as an independent contractor allows shoppers to set their own schedules, offering a convenient side hustle or part-time job option. Understanding how shoppers are compensated can give you a better appreciation of the service they provide.

Earnings Potential

Instacart full-service shoppers can earn between $7 to $10+ per grocery batch, plus tips. On average, shoppers make about $15 per hour, with potential earnings of $15 to $25+ per hour during peak demand times. Factors such as the number of items, delivery distance, and tips can significantly influence earnings.

Additionally, market demand and batch size affect how much an Instacart shopper can earn. Shopper ratings and batch priority also play a role in the availability of orders. With the potential to earn more than $10 per order, shoppers can increase their income by providing excellent service and receiving tips.

Payment Methods

Instacart shoppers have a preloaded payment card. This card is provided by Instacart for purchasing groceries. They receive their payments weekly through direct deposit, with a minimum earnings threshold of $5. The Instant Cashout feature allows quicker access to earnings for a fee of $0.50.

If a shopper’s payment card runs low on funds, they should contact Instacart customer support through the mobile app to resolve the issue. This system ensures that shoppers have the necessary funds to complete their orders efficiently.

Managing Taxes

Instacart full-service shoppers are classified as 1099 contractors, meaning they are responsible for their own taxes. As independent contractors, they must manage their own tax obligations, including filing quarterly estimated taxes. Since taxes are not withheld from their pay, shoppers need to set aside funds for tax payments themselves.

Proper tax management is crucial for maintaining financial stability as an Instacart shopper to help you save money.

Pros and Cons of Using Instacart

Close-up view of online shopping concept
Image by freepik on Freepik

Like any service, Instacart has its pros and cons. User satisfaction often hinges on the affordability of the fees, ease of navigation, and effective communication with shoppers. While many users appreciate the convenience and time savings, others find the varying delivery and service fees to be a drawback.

Ultimately, whether Instacart is considered a good company to work for or use can be subjective and depends on individual preferences. It’s essential to weigh the advantages and disadvantages to determine if the service aligns with your needs.

Advantages

Instacart offers several advantages that make it an attractive option for many. The convenience of shopping from home and choosing between delivery or pickup options can greatly simplify your grocery shopping routine. Busy individuals can benefit by reducing stress and freeing up valuable time for other activities.

Additionally, Instacart provides access to multiple grocery stores, broadening the selection of products available to you. This variety ensures that you can find the specific items you need without having to visit multiple stores physically.

Disadvantages

Despite its benefits, Instacart has several disadvantages that users should be aware of. Customers have expressed frustration over unexpected price increases after placing orders, leading to feelings of being misled. The pricing on Instacart is often higher than in-store prices, which can cause dissatisfaction among customers.

Moreover, issues with order accuracy and customer service have been reported frequently. Many users have received incorrect or missing items in their orders, contributing to negative experiences. Managing account issues, such as being locked out, and receiving inadequate support from customer service can further exacerbate these frustrations.

Inconsistent quality of delivered items, delays, and canceled orders are also common complaints. Poor customer service, including long wait times and unresolved refund requests, can lead to significant user dissatisfaction. These issues highlight the importance of considering all aspects of the service before committing to Instacart.

How to Sign Up and Use Instacart

Getting started with Instacart is straightforward. Create an account by visiting www.instacart.com/signup or downloading the app for iOS or Android. You can sign up using your email or social media accounts for authentication. While you can add items to your cart without an account, you must create one to complete the checkout process.

Placing an order is simple. Add items to your cart, proceed to checkout, and select your delivery options. Features like the ‘Buy It Again’ tab and the ability to add notes for fresh produce can enhance your shopping experience, ensuring you get exactly what you need.

Creating an Account

Creating an account on Instacart is easy. You can register on Instacart.com or via the app by providing your email and creating a password. Alternatively, you can sign up using your Google or Facebook account for quicker authentication.

When setting up your account, consider opting for Instacart+ to take advantage of additional benefits like free delivery and reduced service fees. This can make your shopping experience even more convenient and cost-effective.

Placing Your First Order

Placing your first order on Instacart is a breeze. You can choose items from multiple stores in the same order, making it easy to get everything you need in one go. Adding notes at checkout allows you to communicate specific preferences or substitutions directly to your shopper, ensuring you receive the best possible items.

These features allow you to tailor your grocery shopping experience to your unique needs, making the process smooth and efficient.

Using the Instacart App

The Instacart app is designed to enhance your shopping efficiency. Features like the ‘Buy It Again’ function make it easy to reorder frequently purchased items. Personalized shopping lists and item recommendations based on your purchase history help you find what you need quickly and easily.

Adding specific notes for items like bananas and avocados ensures that your personal shopper knows exactly what you want, improving the overall quality of your order. With these tools, the Instacart app can simplify your grocery shopping experience significantly.

Customer Experiences with Instacart

Collage of customer experience concept
Image by freepik on Freepik

Customer experiences with Instacart vary, but many users report well-packaged and prompt deliveries. The ease of use of the Instacart app is rated 3 out of 5 by users, indicating that while there is room for improvement, the overall experience is generally positive.

Pro tips for using the app effectively are available, helping users navigate the platform more efficiently and get the most out of their grocery delivery service. Understanding these experiences can provide valuable insights into what you can expect when using Instacart.

Positive Reviews

Many customers express satisfaction with the convenience of using Instacart. They appreciate the overall positive experience, especially when paired with attentive shoppers. The majority of items ordered through Instacart arrive fresh and on time, contributing to customer satisfaction.

These positive reviews highlight the potential benefits of the service, reinforcing the convenience and quality that Instacart can provide when everything goes smoothly.

Negative Reviews

However, not all experiences are positive. Many customers express dissatisfaction with late deliveries, indicating that timing can often be missed. Common frustrations include receiving incorrect items, which leads to disappointment in the overall order accuracy.

Issues with customer service responsiveness are also reported, with slow responses to complaints and queries. Addressing these common complaints is crucial for maintaining user trust and satisfaction with the service. Providing detailed notes to shoppers and planning orders well in advance can help mitigate some of these issues.

Alternatives to Instacart

If Instacart doesn’t meet your needs, numerous grocery delivery apps offer similar services. Alternatives include:

Each caters to different customer needs and preferences. Exploring these options can help you find the grocery delivery service that best fits your requirements.

When choosing a grocery delivery service, consider factors such as delivery flexibility, pricing, and availability in your area. These considerations can guide you towards the best alternative for your specific situation.

DoorDash and Shipt

Shipt and DoorDash are popular alternatives to Instacart. Shipt’s membership costs $99 annually or $10.99 monthly, providing unlimited free delivery on orders over $35. This can be a cost-effective option for frequent users.

DoorDash offers grocery delivery without requiring a membership, but it does provide a subscription service called DashPass for $9.99 per month, which reduces delivery fees. This flexibility can be appealing for those who prefer not to commit to a yearly membership.

Amazon Fresh and Walmart Grocery

Amazon Fresh and Walmart Grocery are also strong contenders. Amazon Fresh is now accessible to non-Prime members, although delivery fees vary based on order size. This makes it a versatile option for both Prime and non-Prime members.

Local Store Deliveries

Local grocery stores may operate their own delivery services, which can provide competitive alternatives to larger platforms like Instacart. These local options often offer personalized service and can be a great way to support local businesses while enjoying the convenience of grocery delivery.

Conclusion

Instacart serves as a practical solution for those aiming to simplify their grocery shopping and optimize their time. By connecting users to multiple retailers and offering tailored suggestions, it addresses the demands of busy lifestyles. However, being mindful of costs and potential service issues is essential when considering this service.

Ultimately, the value of Instacart lies in your individual circumstances and priorities. By assessing its advantages and challenges, you can determine if it aligns with your shopping preferences and lifestyle needs. The choice is yours to make, ensuring that your grocery shopping experience is as convenient and efficient as possible.

Frequently Asked Questions

What Is Instacart?

Instacart is a convenient grocery delivery service that connects you with local stores for delivery or curbside pickup, making your shopping experience hassle-free.

How Much Does Instacart+ Membership Cost?

Instacart+ membership costs $99 per year, giving you perks like free delivery on orders over $35 and 5% credit back on pickups. It's a great way to save money if you order frequently!

How Do Instacart Shoppers Get Paid?

Instacart shoppers get paid through weekly direct deposits for the groceries they buy and deliver. It's a straightforward way to earn money while helping others get their essentials.

What Are the Main Advantages of Using Instacart?

Using Instacart is super convenient because you can shop from multiple stores all in one place, saving you time and effort in your busy schedule. It’s a great way to make grocery shopping easier!

Are There Any Alternatives to Instacart?

Absolutely, you have plenty of options! Consider Shipt, DoorDash, Amazon Fresh, Walmart Grocery, and even local store delivery services for your grocery needs.